3/19/2005

Terri Schiavo: Signpost on our Road to Self-Destruction

As of this writing, the feeding tube sustaining Terri Schiavo's life has been removed and the process of death by deprivation of food and water has begun. Admittedly this whole process has been infuriating to watch unfold as godless judges assuming absolute knowledge about the nature of life act with such amazing arrogance.

It boggles the mind to watch our society move toward such practices as euthanasia without the slightest regard for historical precedent and the inevitable implications for the future of our society. We are traveling the road that every other civilization in history has traveled on the way to their own destruction and yet we seem oblivious to the signposts. We blindly and somewhat arrogantly plunge headlong into the same direction as if we will this time somehow avoid the same consequences which befell every other such civilization.

The longest lasting civilizations in all of human history were also the most moralistic; the Confucian lasted 2100 years, the Islamic - almost 1400 years, and the Roman - about 700 years, albeit each did vary at points from Biblical moral truth. Nonetheless these cultures held to a strict moral code throughout their most prosperous eras. The longest lasting moral order in history is that of Mosaic Law: which structured Jewish life and then Christian life for more than 3500 years.

The unique distinction is this - in each of these cultures their source of moral authority was transcendent - it existed outside and above themselves. This is what maintained the authority of the moral order by means of the conscience. The moral order could also be recognized as an objective standard confirmed in nature and the reality of human experience. It was therefore not subject to the whims of men but rather men were subject to it. In essence, it could be argued that their longevity was directly related to their cultural commitment to a higher moral order.

Now, contrast that with those societies where the source of moral authority was not transcendent but originated within man or more specifically a man or a group of men within that society. These were the shortest-lived societies in history. The Third Reich lasted only 11 years, the Soviet Union, the first formally atheistic society and the longest surviving such society lasted only 72 years.

In every previous civilization they came to rebel against the universal moral order which in turn altered their view of human life. They abandoned the "intrinsic" value view of human life opting instead for a more utilitarian view, what we now call "quality of life." Once that door was opened and the cultural consensus shifted in its view of morality and life they began their decline. Of course there are a multitude of factors that contributed to each culture's demise but it always began with a cultural shift in the area of morality and ethics. In every instance, once a civilization began to embrace a basis for moral truth that was redirected away from a transcendent and universal source to men themselves what followed was the inevitable moral degeneration and ultimate collapse of that society.

America has already experienced moral degeneration in almost every category; what the Terri Schiavo case demonstrates is that our decline is indeed continuing. The tragedy is that we as a nation seem to ignore the warning signs or signposts along the path to our own destruction. (Abortion on demand could be considered a flashing billboard!) Instead we foolishly trust in our own "wisdom," a consequence of the Enlightenment which has convinced the majority of citizens that we can accomplish or resolve anything with enough human reason including the ultimate human dilemma: death and separation from our Creator. As the Bible says, 'there is a way that seems right to a man but in the end it leads to death.' Proverbs 16:25 But again, history demonstrates that this is pure folly and we too will follow the path of every defunct civilization if we do not awaken to our peril, repent and acknowledge the Judge of the universe as the Author of all life and the only one able to give it and take it away!

5 Comments:

At 9:27 AM, Blogger S. Michael Craven said...

I certainly cannot claim to have comprehensive answers to such challenging questions. I am convinced however, that the current state of affairs; the road that has brought us to this point, originates in the Church's loss of relevance in mainstream culture. Therefore the Church must first recognize its failure, the causes thereof, and repent of its unfaithfulness to press Christ’s Lordship into every area of life and culture. This is not a process that has occurred over the last decade but rather the last century and the steps toward true relevance to real life that results in cultural leadership will also be slow, perhaps over generations. Nonetheless, the results are not our primary concern; it is instead faithfulness to the calling of Christ. For it is Christ alone that can and does change the hearts of men and subsequently they the culture. I think 2 Corinthians 10:5 offers us the best course of action in light of our present situation. We simply must equip ourselves intellectually to make "rational" arguments against these false pretensions about what is true that ultimately serve to keep people from knowing God. This remains one of our primary callings in the world; to bring every thought (idea) captive and make it obedient to the truth of Christ who sustains the world and everything in it by His power.

 
At 7:37 PM, Blogger S. Michael Craven said...

I would add that perhaps we call on ALL Christians to pray.

 
At 7:45 PM, Blogger Wirthy said...

everyone is making it seem like being in a vegetative state is a horrible way to go through life. it's not so bad, take it from me.

 
At 9:10 AM, Blogger BA said...

What you wrote 3/19 is so full of truth Michael. My heart breaks for Terri and her family. My prayer has been that they truly know Christ as their Savior. That each may, through Him, receive eternal life.

What baffles me is that homosexuals, who surely represent less than 1% of the population of this country, are so effective at pushing their agenda. Yet we Christians, who must represent a far larger percentage of the population, are losing ground left and right. If only we could become truly unified. This is a reflection of the true state of the hearts of so many professing Christians. Many are called, but few are chosen. God help us.

I am appalled that it appears so many in the church are practically ignoring this issue. Sure, I hear some on the radio talking about it, but there appear to be far too many that are completely silent on the issue. Then again, with the infiltration of the world into the church, perhaps it is no wonder that the so-called “church” is so ineffective. What a telling time this is. God help us.

I apologize for my tone, but this issue has frustrated me greatly. We are so blessed to have Christ in our hearts. So many need Him. I pray the Lord will open many eyes and hearts through this situation.

 
At 2:38 PM, Blogger S. Michael Craven said...

Ty,
In response to your question, the media has continually framed the Schiavo case as one in which she is in a "persistent vegetative state." This is a legal term giving the implication that she is "brain dead" and only being kept alive by artificial and extraordinary means. If this were the case I too would argue for the removal of such artificial means and thus allow the "natural" occurrence of death. Terri is not brain dead in this same sense. She has certainly suffered brain damage leaving her profoundly impaired but her bodily functions are normal and therefore capable of sustaining her own life as we are presently witnessing following the removal of her feeding tube more than a week ago. The only thing she is incapable of with regard to life is feeding herself but this also the case in many other instances where patients might be incapacitated not mention newborn babies. We would never think of starving these people to death, at least not yet, although I would say that with the Schiavo case we very well may do so in the near future. Incapacitated is not dead! The present decisions regarding life and death are being based upon assumptions of "quality" or a utilitarian basis. This denies the "intrinsic" value of all life. If this is not the standard to which we adhere and instead opt for a utilitarian approach we will then make decisions at every stage of life based on someone's perception of what constitutes "quality of life." This is the first step in the acceptance of terminating the aged, infirmed, and handicapped. This had disastrous results in Nazi Germany and it will produce the same culture of death here as it has also produced in parts of modern day Europe.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home